Player	Position	Year(s) Selected
Von Factor	DL	23
Gio Kennedy	OL	23
Ben Lilly	OL	23
John Roland	SAF	23
Jaden Manley	WR	22
Rossy Moore	LB	22
DeAndre Parker	RB	22, 23
Carson Barrett	OL	21, 22
Malik Britt	DB	21
Duke Hill	DL	21, 22, 23
Eli Beers	DL	20
Max Craig	OL	20
Derrick Harvey Jr.	WR	20
Josh Jones	DB	20, 23
Mason McMillen	LB	20, 21, 22, 23
Braxton Plunk	OL	20, 21, 22, 23
Wayne Ruby Jr.	WR	20, 21, 22, 23
Jesse Vail	DB	20, 21, 22
John Valentine	C	20, 21
Derrick Bradley	DB	19, 22
Kordell Ford	DB	19, 20, 21
Joey Presutti	C	19
Sean Sherman	OL	19
Johnny Todd	OL	19
Danny Robinson	LB	18
Louis Berry	DB	18
Luke Herrington	WR	18
Brendan Klaus	OL	18, 19
Josh Petruccelli	RB	18, 19, 21
Andrew Roesch	DL	18, 19
Trey Williams	LB	18, 19
Elijah Berry	DL	17
Gabe Brown	DB	17, 18
Matt Fitchet	OL	17
D'Angelo Fulford	QB	17, 18, 19
Brian Groves	DB	17
Justin Hill	WR	17, 18, 19
Alex Louthan	K	17
Cole Parrish	OL	17
Jared Ruth	WR	17
Austin White	DB	17, 18
Charlie Dear	LB	16, 17
Tim Kennedy	RET	16
Brooks Jenkins	OL	16
Mike Vidal	DL	16, 17
Jake Antel	K	15
Mitch Doraty	OL	15, 16
Mike Furda	DL	15
Will Hiteshue	DB	15
Roman Namdar	WR	15
Logan Nemeth	RB	15
Taurice Scott	QB	15
Michael Frank	OL	14, 15
Bradley Mitchell	RB	14, 16
Cody Pogorelc	LB	14
Edward Ruhnke	K	14
Hank Spencer	LB	14, 15
Jonathan Gonell	LB	13, 15
Tre Jones	DB	13, 14, 15
Alex Kocheff	DB	13, 14, 15
Tom Lally	DL	13, 14, 15
Luc Meacham	TE	13
Jack Nicholls	WR	13
Kevin Burke	QB	12, 13, 14
Chris Denton	RET	12
Mac Knisley	OL	12
T.J. Lattimore	RB	12
Frank Orteca	DL	12
Isaiah Scott	DB	12
Shannon Stewart	TE	12
Tyler Almeida	K	11, 12
Jasper Collins	WR	11, 12
Charles Dieuseul	DE	11, 12
Nick Driskill	DB	11, 12
Matt Fechko	DL	11, 12, 13
Matt Mattox	OL	11, 12
Jeremy Murray	RB	11
Arthur Smith	LB	11
Antonio Tate	OL	11, 12
Lambert Budzinski	DL	10
Brett Ekkens	C	10, 11
Alex Ferrara	DB	10, 11
Samy Guerrero	OL	10
Chaz Jordan	DB	10
Caleb Crowl	OL	09
Sam Kershaw	LB	09, 10
Judd Lutz	LB	09
Drew McClain	DB	09, 10
Kyle Miller	TE	09, 10
James Herbert	DL	08, 09
Matt Williamson	DL	08, 09
Chas Yoder	LB	08
Daryl Ely	DB	08
Roger Stewart	DB	08, 09
Cecil Shorts III	WR	08, 09, 10
Chad Reynolds	TE	08
Mike Nitz	C	08
Luke Summers	OL	08
Pat McCullough	DL	07
Tim Reash	OL	07
Greg Micheli	QB	07, 08
Matt Zimmerman	K	07
Jonah Wilson	DB	07
Tony DeRiggi	LB	07
Justin Wray	ST	07
Nick Parr	DL	07
Pierre Garcon	WR	06, 07
Matt Rees	LB	06
Derek Blanchard	OL	06, 07
Nate Kmic	RB	06, 07, 08
Justin Stickley	DL	06
Matt Kostelnik	DB	06, 07
Eric Safran	C	06, 07
Scott Casto	WR	05
Mike Gibbons	LB	05
Jason Lewis	OL	05, 06
Aaron Robinson	RB	05
Ross Watson	DB	05
Jesse Wells	DL	05
Buddy Wolf	DL	05
Zac Bruney	QB	04
Jesse Clum	DB	04
Johnny Josef	DL	04
Tom Manning	OL	04
Rick Prescott	OL	04
Bob Bradley	OL	03
Antoine Dillard	DL	03
Anthony Frate	LB	03, 04
Drew Hanley	TE	03, 04
Mike Miller	DB	03
Shaun Spisak	LB	03, 04
Dustin Blake	DB	02
Justin Coston	C	02
Larry Kinnard	OL	02, 03
Randell Knapp	WR	02, 03
Brent Miller	OL	02, 03
Josh Liddell	TE	02
Todd Braden	DL	01
Matt Campbell	DL	01, 02
Jason Candle	WR	01
Rodney Chenos	K	01
Adam Indorf	OL	01
Chris Kern	DB	01, 02
Ed Malone	C	01
Jason Perkins	DE/OLB	01
Dan Pugh	RB	01, 02
Stan Watson	ST	01, 02
Ryan Belaney	DL	00
Brian Cassidy	DB	00
Matt LaVerde	ILB	00
Jesse Pearson	DE/OLB	00
Gary Smeck	QB	00
Matt Domin	DL	99
Jason Gerber	OL	99, 00
Brooks Greenleaf	DB	99
Adam Irgang	TE	99
Adam Marino	WR	99, 00
Chuck Moore	RB	99, 00, 01
Bill Rychel	OL	99, 00
Tom Bauer	C	98, 99
Kris Bugara	DB	97, 98
Rich Goebelt	DE/OLB	98
Ryan Gorius	RB	98
Jason Hall	ILB	97, 98
Darin Kershner	WR	98
B.J. Payne	DL	96, 97, 98
J.W. Wearley	OL	98
Jeremy Yoder	DL	98
Bill Andrea	PK	97
Mark Black	DB	97
Bill Borchert	QB	95, 96, 97
Jim Eismon	DL	97
Kevin Knestrick	WR	96, 97
Brian Tyla	TE	97
Joe Weimer	OL	96, 97
Brian Flinn	TE	96
Sean Moore	DB	95, 96
Josh Weber	OL	96
Brian Wervey	DE/OLB	95, 96
Matt Liggett	DL	95
Rick Rofe	C	95
Jeff Starkey	DL	95
Mike Wenderfer	OL	95
Todd Zufra	WR	95
Dan Capozella	ILB	94
Richard Dine	DL	94
Joe Jeckel	DB	94
Matt Johnson	OL	94
Sean Lyons	WR	94
Rob Rodgers	OLB	93, 94
Jim Frink	DL	93
Jim Gresko	RB	93
George Rodich	OL	93
Jay Sawvel	ILB	93
John Smith	C	93
Rob Atwood	TE	92, 93
Jim Ballard	QB	92, 93
Chris Dattilio	ILB	92
Tim Dreslinski	K	92
Mike Elder	OL	92
Mike Hallett	DL	92, 93
John Lynch	DL	92
Steve Rogers	DB	92
Jeff Bartolet	OLB	91
Ed Bubonics	WR	91, 93
Chuck Froehlich	OL	91
Roger Winslow	DB	91
Brad Petro	QB	90
Dike Dawson	OL	90
John Bouloubasis	C	90
Dean Paul	RB	90
Tim Hawk	DL	90
Dave Lasecki	LB	89, 90
Brad Barringer	DB	89
Brian Coffee	TE	89
Ron Pawlus	OL	89
Mike Garn	RB	89
Ken Edelman	PK	88, 89, 90
Ed Hogya	WR	88
Paul Hrics	C	87
B.J. Tedesco	DB	87
Keith Rybarczyk	QB	87
Russ Kring	RB	86, 87
Bill Eyer	WR	86, 87
Chris Weber	DE	86, 87
Mike Groff	OL	86
Dave Kowalski	OL	86
Scott Gindlesberger	QB	86
Mike Jarrett	DL	86
Tony Tarantino	RB	85
Doug Hoff	OL	85
John Heather	DL	85
Roger Miller	DL	85
Vic Harris	DB	85, 86
Doug Boyle	K	84
Troy Starr	LB	83, 84
Rick Gershom	TE	82, 83
Steve Harter	OL	82, 83
Rick Hairston	WR	83
Tony Colao	QB	82, 83
Dave McLaughlin	RB	81, 82
Phil Tartt	RB	81, 82
Mark Kingston	DL	82
John Martin	LB	82
Larry Reeder	DB	82
Joel Campbell	OL	80, 81
Dan Reisinger	OL	81
John Szpak	DL	81
Doug Wells	LB	81
Paul Roninger	RB	80
Ward Smith	LB	80
Dan Boros	DB	79, 80
Mark Paghi	C	79, 80
Darryl Hastings	OL	79
Paul Gulling	WR	77, 78, 79
Joe Toth	QB	79
Claude Charlillo	RB	78, 79
Dave Hook	K	78, 79
Jeff Teece	DL	78, 79
Dan Boros	DB	79
John Teece	OG	78
Mike Gutowski	OT	77
Bill Sumser	DB	77
Don Lape	DL	74, 75, 76
Frank Maietta	C	74, 75
Mike Gillespie	RB	75
Mark Choppa	RB	74, 75
Gary Frost	QB	75
Dan Pugh	DL	75
Steve Slater	DB	75
Rick Campbell	TE	74
Craig Deubner	DB	74
Bruce Cartwright	WR	71
John Kennedy	DE	71
Mike Warbel	OT	70
Mike DiBlasi	RB	70
Dale Kanouse	OG	69
Perry Bourn	DB	68, 69
Frank Sachire	OT	65, 66
Dick Rose	DB	66
Roger Headland	OG	65
Bob McClain	C	65
Ralph Roberts	HB	62
Virg Stroia	C	60, 61
John Arbie	MG	61
Bill Davis	DB	59

(Note: The 2020 season did not have First or Second Team due to the shorten COVID-19 Spring season.)